Employment Relations FAQs
ask a question.
       
 
find out about:
""
fact sheets
""
publications
""
order a publication
""
Employment Case Summary
""
EMPLOYMENT CASES SUMMARY January/February 2009 - Table of Contents
""
Compensation and Cost Award Tables
ER Info

Compliance Order - Employment Relations Act 2000

 
 

Previous Section | Table of Contents | Next Section

Carroll v Silver Fern Farms (PPCS) Ltd

12 Dec 2008, P R Stapp, WA 166/08, (7 pages)

COMPLIANCE ORDER - Employment problem arose regarding arrangements for applicant's medical treatment for hearing loss/disability - Parties reached mediated settlement - Applicant claimed respondent did not honour mediated settlement and had not provided hearing aids as promised - Applicant claimed told by occupational nurse that would be entitled to hearing aids - At investigation meeting, applicant accepted that wording of mediated settlement was not that respondent would buy hearing aid - Authority found applicant unable to prove that respondent agreed to buy applicant hearing aid - Record of settlement made no express provision for respondent to arrange and buy applicant hearing aid - Record of settlement stated respondent to action applicant's claim, which respondent had done - Wording clear and unambiguous - Whatever applicant understood was meant was not converted in writing to mediated settlement - Authority found document submitted to Authority after investigation meeting did not assist applicant - Authority found not matter for compliance order

Result: Application dismissed ; Costs reserved

Labour Inspector (Henning) v Broadbat Ltd

20 Dec 2007, H Doyle, CA 154/07, (18 pages)

ARREARS OF HOLIDAY PAY - Identity of respondent - Employees employed by third party which sold business to respondent - Respondent now employer - Applicant Labour Inspector sought compliance with respondent's statutory obligations on behalf of five former and two current employees - No appearance by respondent - Arrears due and owing to employees - Interest 9 percent - PENALTY - Applicant sought penalty for respondent's failure to calculate and pay holiday pay and to provide records as requested - Separate penalties awarded for number of breaches - $200 for failure to calculate and pay holiday pay - Failure to provide records for former employees resulted in three $500 and one $600 penalty - Failure to supply records when requested by two current employees considered aggravating factor, $1,000 penalty for each breach - COMPLIANCE ORDER - Respondent ordered to comply with request to provide records

Result: Application granted ; Arrears of holiday pay ($2,320.95)(GM) ; ($1,979.95)(GP) ; Compliance ordered ; Penalty ($200)(s75 Holidays Act) ; ($4,100)(Total for failure to supply records to six employees) ; Disbursements in favour of applicant ($70)(Filing fee)

Service and Food Workers Union Nga Ringa Tota Inc. v European Master Butcher Ltd

15 Dec 2008, P R Stapp, WA 167/08, (2 pages)

COMPLIANCE ORDER - Applicant sought deduction and payment of union fees under s65A ERA - Authority found union member employees' individual employment agreements ("IEA") did not exclude or vary effect of s65A - Consent given by employees for deduction of union fees from wages and remittance of fees to applicant - Respondent agreed to comply with legal requirement that where consent given to deduct fees then fees to be paid to union in accordance with agreed arrangements - Compliance ordered

Result: Compliance ordered ; Costs reserved

Previous Section | Table of Contents | Next Section


publications order form

home | holidays | pay | good faith | union matters | education & training | fact sheets | publications | parental leave | employment agreements | problem solving | collective bargaining

search our FAQs | sitemap | contact us | about this site | about ers | related sites | govt.nz

©2004 copyright | disclaimer | privacy statement | comment on this website | accessibility

Department of Labour.